De Beers stake may delay buyer payouts
The logo of diamond producer, De Beers. PHOTO: FILE/REUTERS

De Beers stake may delay buyer payouts

Former De Beers Botswana chief executive Sheila Khama has warned that Botswana could wait years before receiving dividends from its proposed increase in De Beers shareholding from 15% to 30%, if private investors finance the acquisition and recover their investment before the government receives returns.


In a commentary on President Duma Boko’s State of the Nation Address, Khama said the government had not explained the acquisition cost, the assessed market value of the additional shares or the financial returns Botswana could expect.


Her remarks follow Boko’s announcement that Botswana intends to exercise its pre-emptive rights to double its ownership of De Beers. The proposed ownership structure would also involve private investors, Namibia and Angola.


Khama said the acquisition could strengthen Botswana’s position in the global diamond industry, but cautioned that a larger shareholding would not automatically translate into greater financial benefits.


“The acquisition of the 30% is not an end in itself,” she said.


Financing and dividend risks


One of Khama’s principal concerns is how Botswana will finance the acquisition and the implications for public finances, sovereign borrowing, foreign reserves and creditworthiness.


She said a private consortium could fund the additional shareholding, potentially removing the need for an immediate cash contribution from Botswana.


However, private investors could negotiate terms allowing them to recover their capital and repay associated debt before shareholders benefiting from carried interests receive distributions.


This could leave Botswana holding a larger stake in De Beers without receiving immediate income from the additional shares.


Khama stressed that the implications would depend on agreements yet to be negotiated. She said the government should explain the expected rate of return and the timeframe for recovering the investment.


Commercial agreements still outstanding


Khama cautioned that the proposed ownership arrangement remained at an early stage, with several commercial agreements still requiring negotiation.


The private consortium would first need to undertake extensive due diligence on De Beers’ finances, mineral resources, operating companies, existing agreements and legal frameworks.


A joint venture agreement would establish the ownership structure, shareholders’ rights and obligations, board representation and appointment of senior executives.


A separate operator’s agreement would determine the authority of the private consortium expected to manage the company, including its responsibilities, performance standards and compensation.


Diamond sales agreements would also require scrutiny, including arrangements involving Debswana in Botswana and Namdeb in Namibia.


Khama questioned how De Beers’ existing relationship with Botswana’s Okavango Diamond Company would operate under the proposed structure, and whether the different diamond marketing arrangements would be consistent with the consortium’s commercial strategy.


Mining leases across De Beers’ operations would also be important, as investors would want assurances that mines could continue operating long enough to recover their investment.


Khama argued that these negotiations, rather than the percentage of shares acquired, would ultimately determine the benefits Botswana receives.


Botswana's role in De Beers' decisions


The former executive also challenged Boko’s criticism of De Beers’ historical decisions, particularly the reduction in generic advertising for natural diamonds.


Khama acknowledged that De Beers’ advertising campaigns had played an important role in stimulating diamond demand and supporting prices. However, she argued that Botswana had contributed to the decline in advertising expenditure through decisions affecting the company’s revenue.


She said Debswana had previously contributed to diamond advertising costs, but Botswana subsequently withdrew its contribution.


The establishment of Okavango Diamond Company also reduced the volume of diamonds marketed exclusively through De Beers, affecting the company’s income.


Khama argued that Botswana could not distance itself from decisions in which it had participated as a shareholder.


“So, no, Mr President. We were part of that decision,” she said.


She also disputed the suggestion that De Beers had independently entered the synthetic diamond jewellery market without Botswana’s involvement.


According to Khama, earlier agreements required the company to consult Botswana before pursuing such a strategy, with the country's representatives participating in the decision-making process that authorised the move.


Technology and regional cooperation


Khama welcomed Boko’s intention to expand Botswana’s participation in De Beers’ technology subsidiary, Element Six, which develops synthetic diamond materials and other products for industrial applications.


However, she questioned why Botswana had not pursued similar opportunities through its existing shareholding.


She recalled an initiative around 2007 involving the University of Botswana and De Beers to explore research partnerships in geology, mining, diamond sorting, valuation, processing and synthetic diamond technology.


Khama said the initiative had not been fully developed, arguing that Botswana should make greater use of De Beers’ technological expertise rather than concentrating primarily on revenue from diamond mining.


She also questioned why negotiations for the proposed acquisition were being coordinated through the Office of the President, working with Minerals Development Company Botswana and selected local and international advisers, rather than through conventional arrangements involving the ministry responsible for minerals.


She argued that established government institutions should be strengthened rather than bypassed when handling major national investments.


Khama welcomed the proposed participation of Namibia and Angola, saying regional cooperation could strengthen the position of southern African diamond-producing countries.


Dynamics of partner-countries


However, she warned that the three countries had different mining industries, legal systems and economic priorities.


Namibia, she said, was a longstanding De Beers partner with legal and institutional arrangements relatively similar to Botswana’s, while Angola offered substantial mineral potential but operated under a different legal framework and had an economy less dependent on diamond revenues.


Khama said these differences would complicate the management of a joint venture involving governments, private investors and financiers.


“This will be a difficult joint venture to run,” she said.


She maintained that the partners would need to reconcile competing commercial and national interests while ensuring the company remained financially sustainable.


Khama said Botswana’s ambition to become the largest individual shareholder in De Beers should ultimately be judged by the value it delivers to the country, rather than the size of its shareholding.


The proposed increase from 15% to 30% has not yet been completed, with the acquisition price, financing arrangements and final commercial agreements still subject to negotiation.

Advertisments